Due to the COVID -19 crisis, KJC Law Firm, LLC has transitioned to a remote workplace. We are committed to doing our part to reduce the spread of the virus.

Our attorneys and support staff have full access to telephone messages, email and our files. Our office is almost entirely paperless, and we plan to move our cases forward with videoconferencing tools. Our clients remain our first priority, and we are available to support and assist during this time of crisis.

Our email addresses are as follows: kjcook@kjclawfirm.com; jmartin@kjclawfirm.com; twilton@kjclawfirm.com; bduggan@kjclawfirm.com; mweaver@kjclawfirm.com; jryan@kjclawfirm.com; and dkelley@kjclawfirm.com. Please feel free to contact us.

Articles Posted in Criminal Defense

EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE DOCTRINE OF QUALIFIED IMMUNITY AND HOW IT PREVENTS CITIZENS FROM ENFORCING THEIR RIGHTS AGAINST LAW ENFORCEMENT AND GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS

What is Qualified Immunity for Police Officers? These Six Cases ...

As the national discussion about police reform and Black Lives Matter continues to rise in frequency and importance, it is important to consider one of the greatest hurdles to preventing police brutality: lack of police accountability.  Qualified immunity is a doctrine created by activist judges that permits law enforcement and other government officials to violate people’s constitutional rights with impunity.  Ordinary people—whether they’re doctors, lawyers, or construction workers—are expected to follow the law.  If they violate someone else’s legal rights, they can be sued and required to pay for the injuries they’ve caused.  Law enforcement and other government officials?  Not so much.  Why is this important?  Because nearly all federal and state civil rights statutes empower ordinary citizens to sue law enforcement officers and other government officials for unlawful conduct.  This is very much by design since we know from history that people, corporations, and government agencies change their behavior when they are concerned about liability. Civil rights statutes only protect people if they are enforced and until qualified immunity is revoked, the law is virtually unenforceable.

Under the doctrine of qualified immunity, public officials are shielded from accountability and liability for their unlawful conduct.  They can be held accountable only insofar as they violate rights that are “clearly established” in light of existing case law.  This standard shields law enforcement, in particular, from innumerable constitutional violations each year.  In the Supreme Court’s own words, it protects “all but the plainly incompetent or those who knowingly violate the law.”  In other words, ordinary citizens cannot even pursue a claim against law enforcement unless they can show the officer intentionally committed a crime.  It is under this rule that officers can, without worry, drag a nonthreatening, seven months pregnant woman into the street and tase her three times for refusing to sign a piece of paper.

On November 16, 2017, in Suffolk County Superior Court, a jury of twelve returned a verdict of not guilty in favor of Attorney Benjamin Duggan’s client.  Attorney Duggan’s client was charged with, among other things, illegally possessing a firearm and ammunition.  Due to certain sentencing enhancements, Attorney Duggan’s client was facing a minimum mandatory state prison sentence of 15 years.  Attorney Duggan’s client had been held pending trial for over a year.  Following the jury’s verdict, he walked out the front door of the courthouse a free man.

Issues in the case included a motion to suppress certain items seized pursuant to a search warrant, the legal elements of actual and constructive possession, and various forensic testing including DNA and fingerprints.  The jury’s verdict followed extensive testimony and evidence.

If you have been charged with a crime, contact the attorneys at the KJC Law Firm.  Let our experience secure you the best possible results.

 

Contact Information